What Type Of HDB Flat Can I Really Afford?
 
500
shares

What Type Of HDB Flat Can I Really Afford?

Kenneth Fong
500
shares

So…

You’ve decided to apply for the latest HDB BTO Sales Launch and now have to decide what HDB flat type to choose.

Should you just buy the largest flat that you can afford?

What if you only wish to live in the flat until you meet the Minimum Occupation Period (MOP) and want to sell it?

Are there any considerations that you should think about when deciding between a 3-Room, 4-Room, or a 5-Room flat?

WAIT.

Guy Saying Wait Wait
Source: tenor

Before we get ahead of ourselves, let’s do a little math to find out: what type of HDB flat can you REALLY afford?


TL;DR: Only Buy As Much House As You Can Comfortably Afford

For this exercise, I determined what is the minimum average monthly household income needed when considering which type of HDB flat to get.

How did I do this? I…

  • used the Tengah November 2019 BTO Sales Launch prices as a reference (since it’s one of the most recent launches and has most of the existing HDB flat types – less studio)
  • assumed that I would be taking an HDB housing loan and would put down a 10% downpayment
  • calculated how much Enhanced CPF Housing Grant I would get with respect to my household’s monthly income bracket
  • applied the Mortgage Servicing Ratio of 30%

This is what I found out:

HDB BTO Flat TypeAverage Price
(excluding grants)
Minimum Monthly Household Income
2-Room Flexi$134,700$627
3-Room$232,000$2,100
4-Room$341,500$3,817
5-Room$459,500$5,657
3Gen$473,000$5,910

Feel free to apply my calculations to your respective BTO or Resale flat purchase to see which type of HDB flat you can comfortably afford.


How Much Does The Average HDB Flat Cost?

Apartment Flat

I’ll be taking Tengah November 2019 BTO Sales Launch as a reference since it’s one of the few HDB projects recently which has (almost) all the various HDB types to choose from, namely:

  • 2-Room Flexi
  • 3-Room
  • 4-Room
  • 5-Room
  • 3Gen

The only HDB flat type which this estate doesn’t offer is a studio flat.

Average Price Of The Various HDB Flat Types (Excluding Grants)

Using the indicative prices of the BTO project I calculated the average price of the various HDB flat types:

HDB Flat TypeAverage Price (Excluding Grants)
2-Room$134,700
3-Room$232,000
4-Room$341,500
5-Room$459,500
3Gen$473,000

Average Price Of The Various HDB Flat Types (Including Grants)

Effective 11 Sep 2019, HDB rolled out a new grant, Enhanced Central Provident Fund Housing Grant (EHG) which replaced the existing Additional and Special CPF Housing Grant.

Assuming you and your partner are first-timers who meet all the eligibility criteria for the EHG.

You can expect to receive between $5,000 to $80,000 in grants.

Naturally, the final amount you qualify will ultimately depend on your average monthly income.

Average Monthly Household Income* Over 12 MonthsEHG Grant Amount2-Room3-Room4-Room5-Room3Gen
Not more than $1,500$80,000$54,700$152,000$261,500$379,500$393,000
$1,501 to $2,000$75,000$59,700$157,000$266,500$384,500$398,000
$2,001 to $2,500$70,000$64,700$162,000$271,500$389,500$403,000
$2,501 to $3,000$65,000$69,700$167,000$276,500$394,500$408,000
$3,001 to $3,500$60,000$74,700$172,000$281,000$399,500$413,000
$3,501 to $4,000$55,000$79,700$177,000$286,500$404,500$418,000
$4,001 to $4,500$50,000$84,700$182,000$291,500$409,500$423,000
$4,501 to $5,000$45,000$89,700$187,000$296,500$414,500$428,000
$5,001 to $5,500$40,000$94,700$192,000$301,500$419,500$433,000
$5,501 to $6,000$35,000$99,700$197,000$306,500$424,500$438,000
$6,001 to $6,500$30,000$104,700$202,000$311,500$429,500$443,000
$6,501 to $7,000$25,000$109,700$207,000$316,500$434,500$448,000
$7,001 to $7,500$20,000$114,700$212,000$321,500$439,500$453,000
$7,501 to $8,000$15,000$119,700$217,000$326,500$444.500$458,000
$8,001 to $8,500$10,000$124,700$222,000$331,500$449,500$463,000
$8,501 to $9,000$5,000$129,700$227,000$336,500$454,500$468,000

*Includes ALL working persons’ (applicants and occupiers) income

What’s The Takeaway Here?

The lower your monthly household income, the more grants you’ll receive.

This means that (ideally) you should apply for an HDB BTO as early as possible.

Let’s look at two scenarios:

Couple A

  • One is a final-year university undergraduate ($0 monthly income)
  • The other is a fresh grad with a first job ($2,500 monthly income)

Their monthly household income would be $2,500 which means they qualify for $70,000 in EHG.

Couple B

  • Both have started work for at least one year ($3,000 monthly income each)

Their monthly household income would be $6,000 which means they only qualify for $35,000 in EHG.

See? The difference in grants qualified is almost twice.

But before you even apply, make sure that you’re in a committed relationship and avoid breaking-up after you BTO… it’s a really expensive and messy affair.

How Much Do I Need To Pay For My Monthly Mortgage?

illustration of money transaction

Without getting into the debate of whether a bank loan or HDB housing loan is better, let’s look at how much you’d need to pay if you took an HDB housing loan.

After making the 10% down payment, you would be borrowing the rest at an interest rate of 2.6% per annum for 25 years.

Monthly Mortgage Of The Various HDB Types

Here’s what your monthly mortgage would look like:

Average Monthly Household Income Over 12 Months2-Room Flexi^3-Room4-Room5-Room3Gen
Not more than $1,500$188$585$1,032$1,514$1,569
$1,501 to $2,000$210$607$1,055$1,516$1,592
$2,001 to $2,500$233$630$1,077$1,539$1,614
$2,501 to $3,000$256$653$1,100$1,561$1,637
$3,001 to $3,500$278$676$1,123$1,584$1,660
$3,501 to $4,000$301$698$1,145$1,607$1,682
$4,001 to $4,500$324$721$1,168$1,629$1,705
$4,501 to $5,000$346$744$1,191$1,652$1,728
$5,001 to $5,500$369$766$1,213$1,675$1,750
$5,501 to $6,000$392$789$1,236$1,697$1,773
$6,001 to $6,500$414$812$1,259$1,720$1,796
$6,501 to $7,000$437$834$1,281$1,743$1,818
$7,001 to $7,500Not applicable$857$1,304$1,765$1,841
$7,501 to $8,000$880$1,327$1,788$1,864
$8,001 to $8,500$902$1,349$1,811$1,886
$8,501 to $9,000$925$1,372$1,834$1,909

^Average gross monthly household income for 2-Room Flexi (99-Year Lease) cannot exceed $7,000

If you’re wondering how I got these figures, I used a calculator like HDB’s Enquiry on Monthly Instalment to work out what is monthly mortgage (after deducting the downpayment and grant from the property price).

For young couples who:

  • want to keep their expenses low
  • want to upgrade to a larger property in the future
  • don’t plan to have children

the monthly mortgage for a 3-Room HDB BTO is relatively manageable at under $1,000.

Assuming I use the abovementioned Couple B’s income bracket ($5,501 to $6,000) as an example, they would pay around $789 a month on their mortgage for a 3-Room HDB BTO.

Which works out to be about 13% of their monthly household income.

So why is understanding this percentage important?

Here’s why…

What Type Of HDB Flat Should I Be Getting Based On My Monthly Income?

money bag and hand

This is where we need to be really honest with ourselves and stay within our financial league.

To get a good measure of that, I’ll be using the Mortgage Servicing Ratio (MSR) which caps the amount that you can spend on mortgage repayments to 30% of your gross monthly income.

This way, we have a more realistic way of evaluating how much house you can actually afford.

In cases where the MSR is more than 30%, I’ll indicate it with a “Not Applicable” which means that if you fall within that income bracket and are considering that house, you might want to reconsider your options…

Average Monthly Household Income Over 12 Months2-Room Flexi3-Room4-Room5-Room3Gen
Not more than $1,500$627Not ApplicableNot ApplicableNot ApplicableNot Applicable
$1,501 to $2,000$700
$2,001 to $2,500$777$2,100
$2,501 to $3,000$854$2,177
$3,001 to $3,500$927$2,254
$3,501 to $4,000$1,003$2,327$3,817
$4,001 to $4,500$1,080$2,404$3,894
$4,501 to $5,000$1,154$2,480$3,970
$5,001 to $5,500$1,230$2,554$4,044
$5,501 to $6,000$1,307$2,630$4,120$5,657$5,910
$6,001 to $6,500$1,380$2,707$4,197$5,734$5,987
$6,501 to $7,000$1,457$2,780$4,270$5,810$6,060
$7,001 to $7,500Not Applicable$2,857$4,347$5,884$6,137
$7,501 to $8,000$2,934$4,424$5,960$6,214
$8,001 to $8,500$3,007$4,497$6,037$6,287
$8,501 to $9,000$3,083$4,574$6,114$6,364

From this table, we can see that most income brackets would be able to afford a 2-Room Flexi or 3-Room HDB BTO flat comfortably.

$7,000 monthly household income cap for the 2-Room Flexi (99-Year Lease) aside.

If you want a 4-Room HDB BTO, your minimum household income should ideally be $3,817 or more.

Want to spring for that 5-Room HDB BTO? Your minimum household income jumps up to $5,657 or more.

And lastly, your minimum household income to afford a 3Gen HDB BTO should ideally be $5,910 or more.

What Else Should I Consider When Deciding If I Can Afford A Home?

House Cost

Considering that we’re using an HDB Housing Loan to service the mortgage, it means that we’ll be using our monthly CPF contributions to pay the monthly mortgage.

Some of you might find yourself in a situation where your monthly CPF contribution is insufficient to cover the cost of your monthly mortgage (eg. using one person’s CPF to make payments for the HDB housing loan).

Should you perform cash top-ups on top of your CPF payments in order to ‘afford’ that house?

Yes… and no.

If your cash top-ups come from a steady stream of passive income that is unaffected by unfortunate events like you, unfortunately, losing your job, then sure… why not?

But if you’re using money from your monthly household income to supplement your CPF contributions, then you’ll want to be very careful.

In the unfortunate event where either you or your partner are unable to continuously bring in that extra amount of money to meet your monthly mortgage, you’ll find that your finances will be severely stretched.

Have A Question About Your Property Purchase?

Green Question Mark

Should you go with an HDB BTO or a Resale flat?

Need help with questions like whether you should go with a bank loan or HDB loan?

Why not ask our friendly Seedly community on our Seedly QnA?

Ask Your Property Related Questions Now!

Follow our Seedly communities, be active, and win a 3D2N All-Expense-Paid Trip to Bali for 2!

About Kenneth Fong
Editor of Seedly's blog. Owner of a 4-room HDB BTO and married to a financial clutz. Probably the closest to an adult you can find on the Seedly team.
You can contribute your thoughts like Kenneth Fong here.

Still have more questions after reading the article? Fret not, ask our community here!

Stay updated with the latest finance tips!
Receive bite-sized finance on Telegram here.

What's Popular

    • Loading articles
    • Loading articles
    • Loading articles
    • Loading articles
    • Loading articles
Comments
500
shares

What's Popular

    • Loading articles
    • Loading articles
    • Loading articles
    • Loading articles
    • Loading articles

Still have more questions after reading the article? Fret not, ask our community here!